Creamy Tangy Potato Salad

There's something about potato salad that catches people off guard—it looks simple enough, but somehow it's always the dish that disappears first from the picnic table. I learned that years ago when I stopped overthinking it and just focused on one thing: getting the potatoes creamy and tangy while they were still warm enough to absorb all those flavors. That's the whole secret, really. This version has become my go-to because it's forgiving, comes together in under an hour, and tastes like someone actually cared while making it.

I made this for a small Fourth of July thing once, and my neighbor who usually just nods politely at potluck dishes actually came back for seconds and asked for the recipe. That's when I knew the tangy-mustard balance was right—it's bright enough to keep things interesting, but not so sharp that it overshadows the creamy texture everyone expects.

Ingredients

• Yukon Gold or red potatoes (1.5 lbs, cut into 1-inch cubes): These waxy varieties hold their shape way better than russets, which is crucial since you want distinct potato pieces, not a mushy mess.
• Mayonnaise (2/3 cup): This is your binding base, so don't skimp on quality—it makes a real difference in how creamy everything feels.
• Dijon or yellow mustard (2 tablespoons): Dijon brings sophistication, yellow keeps it approachable; either way, it cuts through the richness and makes the whole thing taste less heavy.
• Apple cider vinegar (2 tablespoons): The acidity is what keeps this from tasting like a mayo bomb; it wakes everything up.
• Salt and black pepper (1/2 teaspoon and 1/4 teaspoon): Season as you taste, because potatoes need more salt than you'd think to actually taste like something.
• Celery and red onion (finely diced): These add texture and a subtle bite that keeps the dish from being one-note.
• Fresh parsley (2 tablespoons, chopped): A small amount brings brightness and a hint of herbaceous flavor without making it taste salad-y.
• Hard-boiled eggs (2, chopped, optional): If you include them, they make it feel more substantial and add visual interest.

Instructions

Keeps spices within easy reach while cooking, helping you season dishes quickly during everyday meal prep.

Check price on Amazon

Boil the potatoes gently:

Put your cubed potatoes in a pot of cold salted water and bring it to a boil, then reduce the heat so they simmer gently for 10–12 minutes until fork-tender. Gentle heat matters—a rolling boil breaks them apart.

Cool them just enough:

Drain them and spread on a baking sheet for about 10 minutes; they should still feel slightly warm when you dress them so they actually absorb the flavors instead of repelling them.

Mix your dressing first:

Whisk mayonnaise, mustard, vinegar, salt, and pepper in a large bowl until smooth and well combined.

Fold everything together gently:

Add the warm potatoes, celery, red onion, and parsley to the bowl and fold carefully with a spoon or spatula so you're mixing without mashing.

Add eggs if you're using them:

Fold in the chopped hard-boiled eggs last, as gently as you folded in the potatoes.

Chill and let it rest:

Cover and refrigerate for at least an hour so the flavors have time to meld together and everything gets properly cold.

Taste before serving:

Give it a final check for seasoning and adjust salt and pepper if needed—chilling sometimes makes flavors fade slightly, so don't skip this step.

Save

Years ago I made this for a backyard dinner where everyone brought something, and someone actually called it their favorite part of the meal. It wasn't fancy or complicated, just thoughtful and made with decent ingredients. That's when I stopped treating potato salad like an afterthought.

The Mayo Question

I know mayo isn't everyone's first instinct, but it's what makes this creamy in a way that actually works. If you're a Greek yogurt person, you can swap half the mayo for Greek yogurt without derailing the whole thing—it'll be lighter and tangier, which some people prefer. Just know it'll taste a bit different, and that's fine. The mustard and vinegar are still doing their job either way.

Variations That Actually Work

This recipe is flexible without falling apart. Some people add chopped pickles for an extra vinegary punch, others throw in fresh dill if they're feeling herbaceous, or a light dusting of paprika for color and warmth. I've had versions with fresh tarragon that were genuinely good. The point is, once you get the base right, you can nudge it toward your own taste without losing what makes it work.

Serving and Storage

This is best served cold, straight from the fridge, alongside grilled meats, sandwiches, or pretty much any casual meal where you want something creamy and sustaining. It'll keep for three to four days covered in the fridge, and it actually tastes better the next day when the flavors have settled in deeper. Don't leave it sitting out in the heat for more than a couple hours—just basic food safety that nobody thinks about until it matters.

• Make it a few hours ahead if you can; the flavor really does improve with time.
• Keep it covered in the fridge so it doesn't pick up other flavors or dry out.
• Give it a gentle stir before serving if it's been sitting for a while, since the mayo settles slightly.

Grind fresh meat, make sausages, and shred vegetables quickly for homemade burgers, meatballs, and everyday recipes.

Check price on Amazon

Save

This is one of those dishes that proves sometimes the most satisfying food is also the simplest. Make it once, own it, and it becomes yours.

Recipe Questions & Answers

→ What type of potatoes work best for this salad?

Yukon Gold or red potatoes are preferred due to their tender texture and ability to hold shape after boiling.

→ Can I prepare the salad in advance?

Yes, chilling the salad for at least an hour allows the flavors to meld beautifully.

→ How can I make the dressing tangier?

Increase the amount of apple cider vinegar or add a touch more mustard to enhance tanginess.

→ Are there good add-ins to vary the flavor?

Chopped pickles, fresh dill, or a dash of paprika can bring additional zest and depth.

→ Is it possible to lighten this dish?

Substitute half the mayonnaise with Greek yogurt for a lighter, but still creamy texture.